AppellateOverflow
Call

Appeal Assessment

$500*

*These are our standard flat rates. An unusually large record or a high number of issues may call for a different price. You'll have the final price in writing before work starts.

Not sure whether a case is worth appealing? We'll review the available record, identify potential grounds for appeal, assess their strengths and weaknesses, and recommend an approach. You'll receive a written analysis to help you decide whether to take the case and how to proceed.

It's also a simple way to see our work before hiring us for more.

What you get

A written analysis you can use with your client. It concludes that the appeal appears strong, mixed, or weak, or that it is too uncertain to assess responsibly on the materials supplied.

What we do

We review the materials you send, within the scope we agree on, research the issues, and write up what we find. Depending on those materials, the assessment covers:

  • The ruling and where the case stands procedurally.
  • Appealability, timing, and preservation questions for you to confirm.
  • Which issues look promising and which look weak.
  • The standard of review for each issue.
  • Candidate arguments and the important contrary authority.
  • Significant gaps in the record, and any transcripts you may need.
  • A concise evaluation of strengths and weaknesses.
  • A proposed approach, or the questions to answer before going further.

Good to know

  • It is a standalone service, not a required first step. After it, you can stop, go ahead on your own, or hire us for more.
  • Unless your quote says otherwise, it is a focused review of the key documents, not an exhaustive review of the full trial record.
  • Ordering an assessment does not pause or extend any deadline. We set the delivery date with any notice-of-appeal deadline in mind.
  • You get one completed written analysis.
  • You decide what to advise your client and whether to appeal.